I thought that rather than focusing just on keeping the Cow Palace as our venue that a list of the needed qualities of a DCF Venue might help find a replacement (if needed) or even some place better.
So here are what I've come up with so far:
Permitable for public assembly, also for food and alcohol consumption
Large enough (I believe that we are currently using about 60,000 sq. ft.)
Secure
Reasonable rent
Able to be occupied for 8 to 10 weeks
Good parking (possibly optional, certainly the parking gods did not look favorably on pier 45)
Reasonably close to major freeways
In or near San Francisco (this one may be optional, but it wasn't the cold that made freezer fair bad, it was the lack of customers)
Able to have the set installed and taken out with out worrying about the structure of the building too much.
Be free of NIMBY issues (goes with permitted uses usually)
Be able to be darkened for theatrical lighting (in other words we don't want great amounts of daylight all day)
allow for acoustic separation of the various areas.
Secondary considerations
Be able to re-use the existing sets (this is a cost issue)
Easily accessible via public transit (the cow palace is not what most people consider easily accessible) (if the parking sucks, then transit is very important)
what else?
So here are what I've come up with so far:
Permitable for public assembly, also for food and alcohol consumption
Large enough (I believe that we are currently using about 60,000 sq. ft.)
Secure
Reasonable rent
Able to be occupied for 8 to 10 weeks
Good parking (possibly optional, certainly the parking gods did not look favorably on pier 45)
Reasonably close to major freeways
In or near San Francisco (this one may be optional, but it wasn't the cold that made freezer fair bad, it was the lack of customers)
Able to have the set installed and taken out with out worrying about the structure of the building too much.
Be free of NIMBY issues (goes with permitted uses usually)
Be able to be darkened for theatrical lighting (in other words we don't want great amounts of daylight all day)
allow for acoustic separation of the various areas.
Secondary considerations
Be able to re-use the existing sets (this is a cost issue)
Easily accessible via public transit (the cow palace is not what most people consider easily accessible) (if the parking sucks, then transit is very important)
what else?
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Tue, March 4, 2008 - 2:43 PMAll that, plus a decent lease: if you only have to build once then having to pay for extra storage and transport is less an issue. Plus a leased (or even purchased) space could be used throughout the year for different events or as income-producing space: studio or workspaces, a period-type dance/pub, classroom, rehearsal spaces. And yes, it could even be an unused hangar in a far corner of an airport nearby---I am all for positive, creative thinking.
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Tue, March 4, 2008 - 2:43 PMJust bouncing an idea...as my knowledge of the location is nil...what about The Presidio? Don't they have some renovated areas or some such? I'm currently outside of S.F.,and don't get much local news on the area. Or...since we back tracked to The Cow Palace...what about Fort Mason? ( Or have we outgrown those contraints? ). Just some thoughts. I know The Fox in Oakland is a no go. -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Tue, March 4, 2008 - 2:44 PMTotally outgrown Fort Mason, unfortunately.
Isn't this all a little premature?
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Tue, March 4, 2008 - 4:23 PMI used to work in public affairs for the Presidio back in the day (when it was still an active installation) and know those grounds like the back of my hand. Unfortunately, just about any facility that could have worked has either been razed or put in "99-year renewable leases" since the land cannot be sold. :-( (I still don't know the actual difference, beyond semantics, between a 99-year renewable lease and a sale ...)
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Tue, March 4, 2008 - 8:23 PMThe renovated areas now contain such things as ILM and LucasFilm.
-
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Tue, March 4, 2008 - 2:46 PMit also has to have the right permits, retrofitting, and no dangers.
I rather like the idea of the Alameda base, but I think it may have some problems about the above. Anyone know? -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Tue, March 4, 2008 - 2:52 PMThe piers at Fort Mason are now all filled with offices, small theatres, etc. No longer big, open spaces.
I keep thinking an old hangar or warehouse at Alameda might just be the thing.
Sure it's premature, but we may have to think about it sometime. I've never really liked the Cow Palace as a venue for the fair, but it's all we have. Much preferred the piers and the Fox Theatre. -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Tue, March 4, 2008 - 3:05 PMTotally agreed on the Piers. The Fox was magical, but really the wrong venue. But the piers....ah... a Dickensian atmosphere if ever there was one! -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Tue, March 4, 2008 - 3:36 PMThe Presidio is not an option
-
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Tue, March 4, 2008 - 4:24 PMAlameda is a Superfund site ... something to take into account. -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Wed, March 5, 2008 - 10:54 PM>>Alameda is a Superfund site ... something to take into account.
Ah polution! Just that added touch of Dickensian reality.
I"m all for hanging signs: Do not lick the walls. Do not eat the dirt. Do not eat off the ground. Thank you.
-
-
-
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Tue, March 4, 2008 - 4:16 PMAdd to that: able to support our electrical and ventilation needs.
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Tue, March 4, 2008 - 4:30 PMIf I may, regardless of any meeting or bill, The Dickens Fair, has to find a new home, sooner rather then later, the more "scouting parties", sent out and the word of mouth spreads, a decent venue is sure to be found. It's only a matter of time (barring any earthquakes), before the Cow Palace will be torn down, or at least go through severe major remodel, earthquake retrofit, handi-capped accessibility, etc..., If a new venue is found, even if it doesn't need a lot of work, one must still reserve such a place at least two years in advance, Fezziwig is right, and those that think it's premature, wake-up. My vote for what it's worth, is try and enlist Sen. Yee, and the others help. -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Tue, March 4, 2008 - 4:32 PMIn Yee's publicity, he DOES state that he'd be willing to help displaced events find new homes. -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Tue, March 4, 2008 - 5:01 PMIn addition to Dickens, I participate in the Golden Gate Kennel Club dog show, and visit the Grand National Rodeo and Horse Show.
I'm curious what venues he might have in mind for *those* two items (which is another topic entirely), because if he move the GGKC show out of San Francisco, he loses the kennel club's support. (Grand National will probably move to Cal Expo.)
I need to write to my own representative, obviously; I'm not one of Yee's constituents.
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Tue, March 4, 2008 - 9:31 PMThere are the series of piers south of the Ferry Building in the more industrial areas, stretching inside the bay toward China Basin and even beyond. Maybe the front half of the pier for parking, the back half for the fair. If it comes to it, Dr. Yee's feet need to held to the fire. -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Wed, March 5, 2008 - 9:19 AMThe piers south of the ball park towards China Basin are readily being redeveloped including by the SF Giants - the one that might possibly be suitable is overflow parking for them and other events such as Cirque. Having just left working down there, I can tell you that all of that is earmarked for condo and business development.
-
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Wed, March 5, 2008 - 2:55 PM<In Yee's publicity, he DOES state that he'd be willing to help displaced events find new homes.>
I don't buy that line for a second. If he wants to come up with alternatives for the Cow Palace events BEFORE the bill is voted on that's one thing, but I think anyone who believes he'll put any effort - let alone an iota of public resources - into helping relocate the Fair after he gets what he wants is, well, let's just say a whole lot more trusting than me... -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Wed, March 5, 2008 - 3:07 PMI'm not suggesting trusting him so much as holding his feet to the fire to fulfill his word. -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Wed, March 5, 2008 - 3:41 PMOh, I am certain he will help ... right after Exxon pays for the Valdez spill. -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Wed, March 5, 2008 - 4:07 PMI'm guessing Pier 45 is NOT an option any more. ( Haven't been down there in some ten years,so have no clue if that's offices,open venue,or what. ). Here's another odd spot... Treasure Island? Or has that all been converted into film studios and the like?
Hmmm...MAYBE,there's a notion in this...if it's film lots and etc....imagine co-producing a Victorian area,that would double for films sets,when we're not using them? Pipe dream or crazy-cool idea?
Treasure Isalnd has parking and easy/direct access. -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Wed, March 5, 2008 - 5:49 PM<<Pipe dream or crazy-cool idea? >>
Both. That would be very cool, but doubt it would/could happen. (The whole money issue always seems to get in the way...)
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Wed, March 5, 2008 - 11:03 PMI wonder if a Coalition of the Displaced, plus possible other artistic endeavors, could band together to rehab, rent, renovate, or otherwise occupy some building, somewhere. What's that old military base that's full of art studios now? Something like that.
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Thu, March 6, 2008 - 12:48 AMI remember actually hearing former Mayor Willie Brown saying that Treasure Island would be the ideal place for the 'Dickens Christmas Fair' and other events. I am told the the problem is the 1940's-sized on and off ramps to the island make traffic a real problem from the bridge. Its a good idea, if its available: maybe a way can be thought around the traffic issue (a parking shuttle? or a ferry?). -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Thu, March 6, 2008 - 9:39 AMMore about Willie Brown: now that he is no longer mayor he is a consultant for land-use issues. He works with groups (developers too I'm sure) to find places for them to do their thing. He might have some ideas and he certainly knows people.
-
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Thu, March 6, 2008 - 8:37 AMPier 45 is now a parking facility in one part, and the permanent home of the Museum Mecanique in another (I was just there last month). -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Thu, March 6, 2008 - 10:15 AMI have not been to the Musee Mecanique in a long time---but couldn't Dickens share a space with them for a season if there's space? Antique mechanical stuff and 19th C. Christmas would seem to go togeher. Maybe provide free entry to the Museum with a Dickens ticket or make it part of the fair, each event drawing for the other. If the Musee found a home, then Dickens can too. -
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Thu, March 6, 2008 - 10:20 AMWhen Dickens was at Pier 45 the first time it took up both sheds. When it took place in '95 it shared with a film crew. It didn't work very well. Sharing one shed would not work at all. Plus, parking is an even bigger nightmare now than it was then -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Thu, March 6, 2008 - 11:02 AMLOL the location of Musee Mechanique is so cheesy. I liked it when it was in the basement of the Cliff House.Agreed.
That location is hopeless. -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Thu, March 6, 2008 - 11:30 AMHey, how about the Palace of Fine Arts if/when the Explodatorium moves? I can dream, can't I?
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Thu, March 6, 2008 - 11:32 AMThalassa said: "The Presidio is not an option." Why not?
Sharon said: "Alameda is a Superfund site." What is that?
So, hey! Heres an idea! We are (or at least we like to think we are) and institution that SF (I believe) loves and adores. By SF, I mean the city / county government of SF. Would they be interested in helping us find a home if we need to, somewhere else in their city? i.e. enlist the city to help us? Because they don't want to lose such a quality event within their city limits?
And what of Willy Brown? Has anyone contacted his office?
-
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Thu, March 6, 2008 - 3:44 PMA Superfund site is one that is so tainted with pollution (in the case of Alameda, this includes JP5 jet fuel leeching into the water system) that it requires Federal intervention for cleanup. When I was in public affairs for the Presidio of San Francisco, prior to the base closing, we narrowly escaped Superfund status ourselves due to a rather aggressive cleanup program implemented by the Army.
The Superfund is a federal pot of money with *billions* of dollars dedicated to environmental clean-up of those sites that are determined to be in dire straits.
As for why PSF is not an option ... as I wrote earlier, any building(s) that would have accommodated adequately have either been razed or given 99-year renewable leases by the Golden Gate National Recreational Area.
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Thu, March 6, 2008 - 8:07 PMKURT said "Thalassa said: "The Presidio is not an option." Why not?"
What used to be the one area of the Presidio that would have been ideal, space-wise, has been renovated ... into ILM/LucasFilm/LucasArts. the remainder does not have buildings large enough to house the Fair. -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Fri, March 7, 2008 - 8:37 AMKarsten, if you are referring to the site of the Letterman Hospital and Gym - which is where the Letterman (Lucas) Digital Arts Centre complex has been built - there was never a facility that would have worked for Fair. Point moot.
On the other hand, the new complex is quite nice, and Lawrence Halprin did the wonderful landscaping (which includes a REAL creek, transported from the Northern reaches)
-
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Fri, March 7, 2008 - 4:00 PMHrm, perhaps my bad memory then. I remembered a complex of buildings as large as where we are now. Either way, it has been bulldozed and "restored" and the area is no longer vacant. So definitely moot point. Which was my point.
-
-
-
-
-
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Thu, March 6, 2008 - 3:45 PMThe Musee only takes up one section; the rest has been given over to being a parking garage for the City.
(And the Musee is already free admission ...) -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Thu, March 6, 2008 - 6:14 PMThe Presidio Trust now governs the Presidio - even if there was a suitable venue within its environs, and even if the Trust would permit such an event, the cost would be prohibitive. Additionally, the Trust is implementing paid parking (all the time, everywhere) while drastically cutting the parking supply -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Fri, March 7, 2008 - 8:58 AMScripsit Therese: Additionally, the Trust is implementing paid parking (all the time, everywhere) while drastically cutting the parking supply
----
And the Park Service cum Trust kept assuring people that the base would be "more open" once the Army left ...
(Yes, I'm bitter ... I loved working there, and anyone who believes that it was non-partisan decisions that closed the Presidio does not remember the politics of Art Agnos and the Missouri in the late '80's.) -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Fri, March 7, 2008 - 1:21 PMThe Trust has done many things well, but certainly not everything. I love working here (the many daily strafings by parrots alone is sublime) but I cannot always agree with the Trust, or the City for that matter -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Fri, March 7, 2008 - 1:31 PM"Trust" is rather an ironic term for them, I find.
-
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Fri, March 7, 2008 - 1:41 PMThe Missouri is still sitting in the mothball fleet. They finished her new pier next to the other ships and Pier 39 but the anti-war movements protested the move. Claimed San Francisco was a peaceful anti-war town...
Ironic considering in WWII San Francisco was a major military transfer point for the war in the Pacific and the homeland... They use to embrace the military...
No one knows how much longer the ships at Alameda will remain, they spend more money than they bring in trying to maintain those ships... Big article on that a year or so ago...
That all said, I still think Mare Island in Vallejo might work. They have some large wharehouses there that are larger than the cow palace bays. Good parking near that area. Semi secluded with two ways on and off the island, the bridge and highway 37. And all the gear is stored on the Island already, cheeper transport costs... And I am sure if they started negotiations with the City now, whom owns the land, they could work out a really good deal. As stated in the news, Vallejo is to declare bankruptcy this month. So anything bringing money in would be a bonus to the city and a win-win for both. -
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Fri, March 7, 2008 - 2:17 PMAnd Red Barn has developed a relationship with Vallejo via the Pirate Festival.
-
Re: What is needed in a venue to host the Dickens Christmas Fair?
Fri, March 7, 2008 - 4:09 PMActually Mighty Mo is a museum in Hawaii.
www.ussmissouri.com/
SF really missed the bus on this one.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
